Making Sense
Politics,Satire,Humor,Commentary,Travel,Cricket, healthcare and mental health.
Thursday, May 29, 2014
Friday, May 16, 2014
LOVE IS ON THE AIR
Tune in KLOK1170 AM
every Monday @ 8pm
and
listen to
Yukti Singh (CEO & Radio Host) on her show
LOVE IS ON THE AIR -
where she talks about relationships, marriage, heart aches & heart breaks.
To advertise or to share your stories, dedications write to her at
www.yuktisingh.comq
Mental Health Month: The Crisis Continues in 2014
May is Mental Health Month: The Crisis Continues
The world and US keeps on inching towards progress in
provision of mental health services to 450 million (World Health Report Geneva
October 4 Report) estimated to be afflicted with a disability which makes
others run away from it. In this month we need to remind ourselves of the
barriers and problems to the treatment and justice for those who are afflicted with highly
debilitating and the most misunderstood disease in the world. We need to do
that to offer hope to mentally ill and assuage people like me who are always
angry with the injustice done to this population which generally lives in
shadows. Some highlights are:
·
Stigma, misinformation, discrimination and
neglect continue to prevent treatment of mentally ill.
·
Tradition ridden and ignorant segments of
society continue to equate mental health problems to personal failure. This
dogmatic belief is the most important impediment to treat mentally ill.
·
The policy makers all over the world are scared
of cost of treatment of mentally ill, while ignoring the cost of this
disability to the society which is much greater. It is one of the top
disabilities over the world.
·
This continues to be a belief in society that
mentally sick persons cannot lead productive lives. This is a myth propagated
by ignorant or those interested in perpetuating the currently broken system. It
is well known in medical community that with proper medical and psycho
therapeutic care , 80% of schizophrenics and 60 % of those afflicted with
depression can lead productive lives.
(WHO Report).
·
As a result of this callousness to 450 million
persons in the world, 40% of countries of the world have no mental health
treatment. 25% do not have the basic drugs to treat mental health. On average
there is 1 Psychiatrist per 100,000 people all over the world.
·
The prevalence of mental health over such a
large scale perpetuates the cycle of poverty. Some mental ailments may emanate
from the stresses and strains of being poor and homeless.
Nearer home in USA one does not find the situation any
better. Our hospitals overmedicate routinely after a brief examination. The
hospitals have no beds and no safety net for mentally ill once diagnosed and
sometimes misdiagnosed. The deinstitutionalization with all the good intentions
to award rights of mentally ill the right to live in a free society was botched
in a big way. E Fuller Torrey a known mental health advocate has stated that
the number of beds per 100000 persons in US is too low. Currently it is 14. He
estimates that that it would suffice to make it 50. Joe Nocera, a NY Times columnist
has summed it up well “What happened to the patients who left the hospitals
after deinstitutionalization was horrendous. State mental hospitals would
release patients with little idea where were they going. They often ended up on
the streets, or in prison, which have become today's de facto mental
hospitals".
In last 6 months we witnessed a rerun of this terrible movie
in my hometown of Las Vegas in Nevada. They were dumping patients to California
with 3 days of medications.
I have been associated with mental health for last 25 years
and had hard time in containing my anger over this dismal state of mental
health in our country. I am also the last person to lose hope over this. Here
are some of the steps those members of society who can devote time to goodwill
of disabled and those associated with mental health can take:
·
Make advocacy a part of your daily regimen. Take
it up with legislatures, legislators, state and federal governments and utilize
all legitimate forums for this purpose.
·
Assist your neighbors and communities by
educating them about treatments, stigma and help wherever needed.
·
Speak out when you notice homeless and use all
available forums to highlight the callousness of the society.
·
Educate your friends and family members on
mental health.
·
Emergency rooms at the hospitals make mentally
sick persons wait for very long times. If you come across such a situation,
advocate for them and get them help.
·
Never forget the election time. Force our
representatives to spend more time and energy on mental health issues.
·
And last but not the least display your outrage
on your sleeve and yell if you need to seek justice for the mentally ill.
Thursday, March 20, 2014
My friend BS Bedi wrote a beautiful piece on Khushwant Singh who died today at 99. Here it is:
Bishan Singh Bedi on Khushwant Singh--
I'm not sure if I'm equipped to do an obit of the mighty S Khushwant Singh 'cos he was senior by more than three decades. Nor was he a 'friend' in the real sense. But I had loads of reverence for the 99 year old institution called Sardar Khushwant Singh, which fell today in normal course!I'd like to think we had a lot in common--national pride was certainly one. Also,our love for scotch & humour, vulgarity was no taboo at all! I'd often get a post card from him, "Pl come and have a drink only if your dirty jokes are aplenty and fresh!".Aparently,he was doing crossword today just before leaving his abode in Sujaan Singh Park. What a lovely way to go just one short of a ton! Once I told him a story of a rich man expressing a weird last wish of serving two large of deluxe scotch to all before and after the funeral, the wish was granted but not before he hit the bucket, the dying man asked for his four!!S Khushwant Singh was in peels. I was very tempted to ask his son Rahul if his Sire had any such wish! Only to be told that doctors were removing his eyes to be donated as per the will of the master writer/author/historian!!On another occasion in Bombay in mid seventies, I was going into the steam/sauna of good old Taj and S Khuswant S was coming out. "What is the latest Bedi saab?". Luckily, I had a good one up my sleeve and let him have it! He just couldn't stop laughing!After about an hour, S Khushwant S walked into the sauna, all dressed up for a formal moment, "please tell me the gist of the story again Bedi saab!"!! I repeated the joke saying he can carry it in his editorial of the Illustrated Weekly if he so desired! And lo behold, he accepted the challenge and carried the joke with relevant alteration! "The original is unprintable and was told to me by none other than the captain of Indian cricket!" he wrote. I was very impressed with his bravado and became an unadultrated fan of S Khushwant Singh.He was an authority on Maharaja Ranjit Singh.There was a do at Vigyan Bhavan in honour of the great Punjab ruler. Atul Behari Vajpayee, the then PM too was there whence prominent leaders from Lahore were also present. Maharaja Ranjit Singh was an illiterate ruler from all accounts. But he was blessed with meaningful intuition to handle the French and British staff in his Darbar. And once the Punjab ruler was convinced of all deliberations he would then go ahead and scribble 'sahi' in urdu, which meant the treaty was as good as signed.Now, while explaining all this to a very interested audience (house full!) at Vigyan Bhavan, S Khushwant turned towards Atal Behari Vajpayee and asked "Mr Prime Minister, when are you going to learn to write the word 'sahi'?!". The whole house came down I vividly remember.My early introduction to the great literary Sardar was through his widely appreciated book on partition "A Train to Pakistan". As a young impressionable Punjabi, I quite enjoyed the interpretation of some the choicest Punjabi swearing by S Khushwant Singh, not as in the Parliament these days, but very authentic all the same, to convey to the Lahoris in right earnest!!!Once I got the feel of the Khushwant factor, it was easy to read/listen to him in all forums and enjoy his subtle and at times, not so subtle obsevations on matters of sex, booze and anything closely nearby!I reckon S Khushwant Singh derived huge vicarious pleasure from snubbing the clergy of all faiths and beliefs. He would claim to be an agnostic and yet did a great job of 'History of the Sikhs'! He would detest all sorts of religious movements on roads. Alas, not many in the Parliament would agree with him publically! That's when he would tear into his opponents ruthlessly!!S Khushwant Singh was the only sikh writer to puncture the collective anti national designs in the Punjab in 70's and 80's, only to earn the sobrequet 'controversial' by the petty minded.I was there at the release of his last book when he was 92 and in a wheel chair. The hall at the Le Meridien was bursting at the seams, with more than 70 percent of the audience from the feminine gender! It was an awesome sight when a youngish lass kissed him on his lips, only to confirm my belief that S Khushwant Singh was loveable/hateable, but never ignoreable!!We'll not see the like of S Khushwant Singh in a jiffy simple because honesty is at such a premium these days. Also, the personal discipline of the Sardar in a glorified bulb was absolutely stunning--sleeping early and getting up very early for almost 80 of 99 years was not at all mythical, it was real!Well, he may have left the world, but I doubt if he'll ever leave our thoughts and book shelves. We, as a nation need to celebrate the life of a man who was a constant reminder of Indianism at its best. RIP.
Saturday, August 18, 2012
Saturday, May 26, 2012
Reflections on Government
Keeping
the Herd Together:
Man is gregarious and seems to thrive
in company. Biology has played a major role in the evolution of man’s behavior
and interaction with other humans. It was very clear from early pre- historic
times that some of us were endowed with more physical power while the others
had more mental prowess. Originally the numbers were the determining factor on
which the humans controlled other humans. Soon the humans with mental prowess
cooked up schemes which started to trump physical numbers only. A pointed stone
could do more damage than a fist. Soon there were leaders and followers. Thunders were installed as Gods and Mountain
caves were the new temples. The smarter bunch conjured up Religion and the Priests
became the heads of first governments. The Priests continue to determine a lot
of government though we now have parallel civilian governments which call the
shots also. The agrarian society kept humans in place for a very long time and
most of their effort flowed into the growing food and feeding themselves. The
conflict was small scale because the natural resources were plentiful. The idea
of a government by some form of entity continued to thrive in form of churches
and the need to defend the communities. The idea of keeping the herd together for
myriad reasons was here to stay.
Abraham Lincoln’s quote “Government is
coming together of people to do for one another collectively what they could
not do as well as or at all privately” in Dall W. Forsythe’s Memos to the
Governor may be cogent but tells us only half a story as to why people come
together. The idea that people get together to do things collectively what they
cannot do privately does not really explain the purposes of this collectivity.
The history of mankind lies in the motivations surrounding this collectivity. The
real question is which way the collective herd is lead by those endowed with
the mental prowess to destroy the other herds. And what a tremendous havoc this
collectivity has caused in many cases.
Destructive
Power of the Herd:
The collective herd led by the most
destructive of leaders armed with lethal weapons like nuclear weapons have killed
about 41 million people in wars waged in every corner of the world in 20th
century only .Sometimes it is based on national pride like when Great Britain
chose to subdue Falkland Islands which killed 30000 people. Ethnic violence in India/
Pakistan partition had killed 800000 people in 3 months. Pol Pot killed
1,770,000 in Cambodia. Civil war in China killed 6,200,000 people. (Milton
Leitenberg 2003 in Cornell University Peace Studies Program). American Civil
war killed about 618, 000 Americans. The American atom bombs dropped on
Nagasaki and Hiroshima set another record by killing about 75000 people within
a week. The wages of collectivity have been swerve and swift. It makes
one think and question the uses of collectives which are now sometimes known as
democratic governments. We also need to remember Hitler and holocaust as an
example of the very destructive nature of the herd. It tried to decimate a
whole community of people. It was later tried on a small scale by Serbs in
Balkans. Rallying and getting together
is not all good
The arrival of industrial age and later
technological breakthroughs have in last few decades handed more power to the leaders
of the herd and it is a concern to the
survival of the world as we know it.
All
is not Lost:
Despite the destructive nature of collectives
to do things together and establish institutions that promote good of people have
thrived and have brought the kind of civility to our societies which clearly
distinguish us from the animalistic nature of human instincts. In most modern
societies the governments and people need each other. The principle of rule of
law is perhaps the most important concept invented in the modern times. It is
not perfect answer to all the human problems but it instills order and brings
peace to communities and societies which improve the quality of lives of
people.
The
Role of Modern Government in Society:
Abraham Lincoln’s words “coming
together” have taken a different meaning in our modern society. First a
government is the only entity that could use force. All other institutions have no such force. So what does it do with this force other
than waging wars? It incarcerates people (more than 2 million in US), it
enforces the economic burden on some and relieves it on others and in reality
can forbid you to do things like driving over 65 miles or eat foods that may
make you obese. And ultimately the meaning of government since Lincoln uttered
his words has been transformed and become highly complex with the modern
technology. The government can watch anyone at home via satellites and other
gadgets. The governments can put bracelets on people and watch them wherever they
go. The video cameras watch you at road intersections. Above all when people
get together to protest or oppose something which the government does, it can
watch you with drones from above and make you a scapegoat.
Laissez
Faire:
An extreme fringe of people argues that
the government’s power to use power to control individual lives through
coercive force and economic controls should end. They in fact would like the
people to be nincompoops. They would like to school children at home, build our
houses wherever we like and as we like. They detest government interventions in
housing, jobs, taxes and other economic activities. These people also feel that
government can do no good and there is no such thing as public good.
Democracy
and Government:
In reality the governments have done a
lot of good to the people they serve although they tend to self destruct at
times. Historically we have come a long way. Firstly, the people can now talk
and discuss the failings of the governments. Facebook and Twitter has shown in
the Middle East that social interaction on the world wide web can confront the
government. Secondly the increasing availability of safety net for the poor, deprived
and oppressed has shown the advantages of collective actions. Thirdly the proliferation
of electoral systems through democracies has made collective actions more
viable. The democracy in large nations however is still a messy business and
the progress towards human good and justice has been terribly slow. Democracies
as practiced in the city states have not translated into good democratic
practices in large monoliths like USA, Russia, India and China. They remain
very imperfect societies where all good had to be muddled through.
Mario
Cuomo was probably the most policy savvy Governor of New York ever. He served
the state very well and saved a lot of money to the state. Yet in the end he
lost the election to an unknown. The people got tired of his budget cutting and
advocating good economic policies.
In the end I must say that Lincoln’s
statement regarding government as getting together of people to do what they
cannot do alone is correct but in an entirely different context than he
thought. We are still trying to find out as to why the elements of governments
that do good for humans are also the instruments to inflict heavy damage to
them.
Saturday, April 14, 2012
Sunday, February 05, 2012
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

